West Milford Hardware: Convenient Local Store with Mixed Reviews

Overview

+1 973-728-9191
www.westmilfordmessenger.com
10 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, USA
Hours

Monday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Tuesday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Wednesday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Thursday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Friday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM

Saturday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Sunday 9:00 AM - 3:00 PM

West Milford Hardware Introduce

West Milford Hardware is a hardware store located at 10 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480, USA. As part of the "Hardware Store Near Me" category, it provides hardware and home improvement supplies to the local community.

You can contact them via phone at (973) 728-9191 or through their mobile number +1 973-728-9191.

Customer reviews for West Milford Hardware highlight its convenience and helpful staff. One customer praised the store's "well stocked" inventory and "conveniently located" location, noting that they were able to "get out quickly." They recommended the store for its surprising range of project supplies.

Another customer appreciated having an "on the hook" business in town, emphasizing its value in times of need. They acknowledged that the prices are "a little higher than the big box stores," but attributed this to the store's privately owned status and the savings on gas.

However, one customer cautioned "non-smokers with sensitive nostrils" about a strong smoking smell inside the store, describing it as feeling "like a big ashtray with tools." They noted that masks did not help. Despite this, they acknowledged the store's "invaluable" convenience.

The reviews suggest that West Milford Hardware is a convenient local store with helpful staff and a good selection. However, potential customers should be aware of the reported smoking smell and slightly higher prices.

Key features of West Milford Hardware include:

Convenient local location
Well-stocked inventory
Helpful and attentive staff
Slightly higher prices than big box stores
Strong smoking smell inside the store (according to some)

West Milford Hardware is a convenient local option, but potential customers should consider the reported smoking smell and slightly higher prices before visiting.

Location

Reviews

Mar 19, 2025

It’s wonderful to have a hardware store in our neighborhood. They are well stocked, conveniently located and you’re able to get out quickly. Highly recommend a quick visit. I think you’ll be surprised at all of the items they have for your next project.
Jul 09, 2022

Great to have an "on the hook" business in town that's there when you need it. Prices a little higher than the big box stores, but that's to be expected in a privately owned establishment. Money that would otherwise be spent on gas. Workers are very helpful and attentive. Just a caution to you non-smokers with sensitive nostrils. Sometimes the place feels like a big ashtray with tools. And masks don't help. That said, in a pinch, they are an invaluable commodity in the town.
Jan 16, 2022

This is my new favorite store! I recently bought reflector sticks, burlap, and today a variety of tarps. They always have EXACTLY what I need, close by and with VERY helpful people! There’s no need for me to drive on Rt.23 to Home Depot for items such as these. I’m sooooo grateful!
Jun 27, 2021

Great little local biz. They have a lot of stuff so you don't necessarily have to go to a big box store for things. I like refilling my bbq grill tank. $20 5 minutes, close to home. Lets all do a better job of Supporting local in town businesses!
Apr 04, 2018

Amazing! Even better than what customer service SHOULD be! I'm not from the area but I was there running some errands. Had a bit of time to kill so I stopped in to grab some materials for a project I'm working on. The woman who helped me (the owner I believe) really took the time to get into the problem solving headspace I needed. She knew from the start that it wasn't going to be a big sale, but she helped me because she is kind, thoughtful, and generous. Thank you!!!